Supporting Arguments for Biogenetic Research
...ng diseases, anywhere from “Down syndrome to breast cancer.” Such a tool can prove to become extremely beneficial in the future as scientist learn more of the intrinsic nature of these genetic flaws in their search for cures to these diseases. - Perception versus reality From “Minority, sick workers fear misuse of health data” The above mentioned article clearly states “HIPAA requires that people be informed as to how, and by whom, their health information will be used. In addition, it gives people the right to restrict continued use or disclosure of their personal health information.” Most of the fear people have has no real base and is mostly due to their uncertainties and lack of knowledge. As people become more aware on how the information is used most of the time, their irrational fears tend to cease. Refuting Arguments against Biogenetic Research - Patenting human genetic technology From “Life Sciences: Morals and genetics” Is it morally right to patent genetic information? In Europe, a patent law strictly prohibits the use of biotechnological advances for what are considered to be “immoral inventions.” The vague argument has no clear definition but has been use countless times to justify restrictions on bioethical research by conservatives. I firmly stand by the belief of such people that such legislation to control genetic research is needed, and until further regulations can be made, cases ought to be studied on a one-to-one basis under the power of an ambiguous law such as this one. - Neglecting or Postponing bioethical research for moral concerns. From “More Scientists Leave USA To Do Stem Cell Research” United States top researchers have been moving to other countries “because of restrictive policies governing stem cell research in America.” Prohibiting bioethical research in the United States is both obstinate and naïve, since it is a reality that research is taking place in other parts of the world, where the developments might not necessary be used with benevolent means. The United States needs to allow the research under new legislation that is urgently needed. - Ethical violations in stem cell research From “Local report to question authenticity of Hwang's work” In South Korea, one of the leading countries in stem cell research, the latest scandal involving stem cell research is the alleged use of “ova from his junior researchers and paid donors.” and reports that “raised suspicions about ethical improprieties.” The line between what is moreally correct and incorrect in stem cell research is rather thin, but when the head researcher itself admits he went too far with his research and resigns, it becomes obvious that moral violations can become problematic. This is yet another call for specific legislation addressing the limits of stem cell research and cloning technologies. - Unknown consequences of genetic testing. From “Surge in genetic testing raises quality concerns” Once again due to the federal government’s indifference and ignorance on overseeing and regulating the biogenetics industry, there are now questions regarding the quality of genetic testing taking place in laboratories throughout the country. Errors in the accuracy of tests such as the gender test on fetus are c...